Antibacterial Soap Containing Triclosan No Better At Killing Germs Than Regular Soap, Study Finds.
The Huffington Post (9/16, Almendrala) reports that a study by a team of researchers at Korea University, Seoul found that antibacterial soap that contains the antibacterial and antifungal agent triclosan was "no better at killing germs than regular ol' soap in both lab and real world experiments." Researchers found that both versions of soap "killed 20 common, dangerous bacterial strains in a lab setting at about the same rate." A real-world experiment confirmed the findings that "both versions of the soap similarly rid hands" of harmful bacteria. Lead researcher Min Suk Rhee told The Huffington Post, "It is more important for consumers to wash their hands correctly and frequently rather than to use the antibacterial soaps containing triclosan." The study was published in Journal of Antimicrobial Chemotherapy.
TIME (9/17) adds that past concerns about too much exposure to triclosan compelled the FDA in 2013 to "require manufacturers to prove that antibacterial soaps are safe to use and more effective than traditional soaps." Health consequences linked with triclosan include breeding resistant bacterial strains, disrupting hormones, and possibly contributing to some cancers. The study noted the antibacterial soap containing triclosan did kill more bacteria faster than regular soap, provided it was exposed to bacteria for at least nine hours. Since it is not typical to wash one's hand for nine hours, the "lesson seems to be that when it comes to washing your hands, you don't need fancy antibacterial brands."
Medical Daily (9/17) notes the researchers also discovered "that there was little difference seen in bug-fighting ability in either hot or tepid water." The authors of the study also "believe that the very nature of hand washing makes it improbable for triclosan to work in soap."
Newsweek (9/17) also reports on this story.
Benjamin Hidalgo-Matlock
Skin Care Physicians of Costa Rica
4000-1054
2208-8206
Please excuse the shortness of this message, as it has been sent from a mobile device.